When Yes Doesn't Mean Yes: Hassan Arshad of Cloudways on US-Pakistan Teams
Hassan Arshad, HR head for DigitalOcean in Pakistan and Global HR Director at Cloudways, on what the world gets wrong about Pakistani talent, when a yes needs a second question, and AI agents on the org chart.
Show notes
In this episode of the Leaders in Talent podcast, host Adriaan Kolff interviews Hassan Arshad, who leads HR for DigitalOcean's 350-person office in Pakistan and is Global HR Director at Cloudways, the Pakistani managed hosting provider DigitalOcean acquired in 2022. Hassan has spent 25 years in HR, mostly in Pakistan with stints in the US, Dubai and Oman, and recorded late in his evening, a normal working day for someone whose boss sits in New Jersey.
The conversation starts with what the rest of the world gets wrong about talent from Pakistan: a country never seen as the region's tech hub, whose talent Hassan calls second to none, with strong English, a serious work ethic and Google and Apple now coming in. He explains the cross-cultural competence work he is building for US and Pakistani managers, why a yes in a high context culture sometimes needs a second question, and the signals that give it away. Then the talk turns to HR inside an AI infrastructure company: a weekly HR AI task force, what Slackbot revealed about the hybrid week, why every headcount request now starts with whether an AI tool can do the job, and how roles freed by natural attrition in a support function went to AI agents without a single human replacement. Hassan closes with AI and job security in Pakistan, HR as a strategic advisor, working across three time zones, and why Western companies should give Pakistani talent a pilot.
Timecodes
01:11 Welcome: Hassan Arshad of Cloudways and DigitalOcean
01:59 25 years in HR and a dual role across Pakistan and Cloudways globally
03:20 What the world gets wrong about talent from Pakistan
06:04 Cross-cultural competence: when a yes needs a second question
08:49 Making it stick: hiring, weekly syncs and the boss's role
10:41 The Culture Map and hierarchy in decision making
12:15 Inside an AI company: five layers and a weekly HR AI task force
14:07 What Slackbot showed about the hybrid week
16:40 Agents on the org chart: no backfills where AI does the job
21:18 AI and job security in Pakistan
22:13 HR as strategic advisor: chatbots, policies and two roles across time zones
25:05 Hiring hard-to-find talent, giving Pakistan a pilot, and what's next
___________________________
Connect with us on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/matchr/
Get in touch with us: https://matchr.io/contact
___________________________
Connect with Hassan Arshad: https://www.linkedin.com/in/hassanarsh/
Connect with Adriaan Kolff: https://www.linkedin.com/in/adriaankolff/
___________________________
Resources mentioned in this episode:
The Culture Map by Erin Meyer, the book Adriaan recommends on cultural differences at work: https://erinmeyer.com/books/the-culture-map/
___________________________
RSS feed: https://media.rss.com/leaders-in-talent/feed.xml
Transcription
[00:01:11] Adriaan: Ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to another episode of the Leaders in Talent podcast. And today, or I must say tonight, I am joined by Hassan Arshad. Hassan, welcome to the podcast.
[00:01:25] Hassan: Thank you. Thanks, Adriaan. Good to see you.
[00:01:28] Adriaan: Hassan, I'm saying tonight. I mean, I'm in New York and it's afternoon, but you're in Pakistan and it's a little later, right?
[00:01:36] Hassan: Yeah, it is. But I work for an American company, so quite used to it now.
[00:01:40] Adriaan: Yeah, I can imagine.
[00:01:42] Hassan: I have to connect with my boss and some of my peers.
[00:01:45] Adriaan: Yeah. No, I can imagine. So I appreciate you taking the time to have this conversation with me. Hassan, give a little bit of context who you are, what your background is, and tell us a little bit more about DigitalOcean, where you currently work.
[00:01:59] Hassan: Sure. So 25 years in HR, mostly in Pakistan with quick stints in US and Dubai and Oman, but primarily in Pakistan. So currently I'm with DigitalOcean, and their Pakistani company is called Cloudways, and it was acquired in 2022. It was a Pakistani startup, a managed hosting provider. DigitalOcean itself is a cloud infrastructure provider. My core role is to look after the Pakistan office, and Cloudways globally. The majority is in Karachi, Pakistan. Karachi is the economic hub. It used to be the capital, still the largest city of Pakistan, one of the largest in the world.
[00:02:41] Adriaan: Yeah. So, and you have a bit of a dual role, right? On the one hand you're CEO of the Pakistani office, which is... how big is the office?
[00:02:49] Hassan: So we have 350 people in Pakistan. So I'm the HR head for the Pakistan office, and for Cloudways specifically, I can, you know, call myself the global HR director.
[00:03:02] Adriaan: Yeah. So you have a little bit of that dual, you know, hat on, right? Like on one hand, local with a pretty significant office, and then on the other hand, also the global HR role that you have. It's interesting to me, right? Because I do feel that a lot of Western leaders do not have enough exposure to APAC and to Asian countries in general. So that's why I was so excited for you to come on the podcast because you have this beautiful bridge of both sides of that story. Before we get into all of the beautiful things around AI, tell me a little bit more about what the rest of the world still gets wrong about talent coming from Pakistan?
[00:03:35] Hassan: So, great question. I mean, a good starting point. So Pakistan, you know, due to its geopolitical situation and the socioeconomic culture, was not considered the tech hub of the region, which was India. We didn't have a Silicon Valley or an equivalent. But when it comes to the talent, I would say they are second to none. I mean, it's one of the tech powerhouses. The only thing was, the political situation did not allow the hyperscalers and the top companies to come and invest in Pakistan in maybe the late '90s and early 2000s. And they just had a token presence and the sales offices in Pakistan. But now things are changing. We have news that Google and Apple are coming in Pakistan. So coming back to your question, I would say, I mean, being the HR manager for them for many years, huge potential, very marketable, great communication, one of the largest English-speaking countries in the world. I mean, we are taught English since the school days, and it's considered a very normal second language in Pakistan. The only thing was we were a very service-oriented corporate culture instead of a product one. We had few product-oriented companies. So Cloudways is one of the few, you know, success stories coming out of Pakistan, where a core product was being made for a decade and then eventually sold through an acquisition.
[00:05:04] Adriaan: Great. Hey, what do people underestimate about the Pakistani work culture or in general in terms of the West and the East?
[00:05:15] Hassan: So, one thing they underestimate is, one, it is reasonably priced well, due to the, you know, currency differences and the labor arbitrage. Secondly is the work ethic. So most of the Pakistani talent is reasonable. You know, they have families to feed. There's an economic crunch going on. The inflation is rising. You know, they mean business. They will deliver you good products on time. They will communicate well. While the international managers need to keep certain cultural nuances in mind, which we may talk about in the next couple of questions. But generally what they underestimate is, one, they are reasonably priced. Good work ethic. Three, very approachable, open to feedback. A little bit of effort can go a long way.
[00:06:04] Adriaan: Amazing. Hey, and what are some of the things that you need to teach your US managers, and what are some of the things that you need to teach your Pakistani managers in order to work successfully together?
[00:06:15] Hassan: Great question. I recently worked on a project called Cross-Cultural Competence. So see, one, there is the overall culture of East and West. So Pakistan is a very high context culture. The respect of hierarchies and a lot of unsaid is being understood, unlike the US where if you say something, you mean it, and if you don't say something, you don't. It's not there in the So what we are trying to build is some content and curriculum on that, "Hey, if your Pakistani colleague is saying yes, just probe a little more. Maybe they need a little help. They may be courteous to say yes." So ask, "Hey, do you need help? Hey, do you need any support? Are you able to meet this deadline?" That is where I believe, the US managers can, you know, go a little more empathetic, eventually see it is a strong language, but it's not our first language. And then we are a very hierarchical, you know, culture. You know, the subcontinent was ruled by British for hundreds of years, and it was a very divide and rule and, a very hierarchical structure. Now, Americans are totally black and white, and they at times may appear very to the point and straightforward. So that is one gap. And on the contrary, if I'm a manager in Pakistan and I'm managing in the US, I may not need to get offended by their very to-the-point updates, their very straight and simple and short answers, not going into fluff. So A bridge needs to happen between the two cultures. I mean, the possibilities are endless.
[00:07:54] Adriaan: Is, because I find it so fascinating with also, like, coming from a... I'm Dutch, right? We are one of the most direct cultures in the world. Is when Pakistani work together and someone says yes, is there a different way of understanding, you know, because you know the culture, when a yes is 100% yes and when a yes is like, "I need to probe a little more"? Is that intuition or is there a specific way on how the yes is articulated that you develop the sixth sense of understanding when someone is really on board and when someone's just being polite?
[00:08:26] Hassan: Well, for us, it's not the sixth sense. It's that we can just figure it out. Someone who is, you know, outside Pakistan, I would say the body language, a bit of reluctance, a bit of missing specifics, you know, committing immediately, not asking questions. So these are some of the indicators that, hey, I need to ask. I need to really dig down into this yes.
[00:08:49] Adriaan: Hey, Hassan, because these examples make a lot of sense, right? But do that on a global scale, how do you roll this out across the organization in embedding this and for people to understand that when they work with different cultures across different time zones, especially the high context versus the low context bit, how do you roll that out and how do you institutionalize that in your organization?
[00:09:09] Hassan: So, you know, it starts with the hiring process. I mean, even when I was being interviewed, I had a number of interviews locally and globally. While the number of interviews felt, you know, excruciatingly high to me, but later I realized this was good for me and the business. You know, we really need to be sure of, especially in lean times, lean teams like us. As HR, we are a very small team, in Pakistan. So, we had to be really careful of who we are getting into the business and where is the possibility of cultural alignment. Once that basic potential is ascertained, then, you know, things are pretty smooth. It's a smooth sailing. Then we do a regular sync. We do a lot of syncs. My week is totally, you know, just a couple of meeting free days, and then I'm connecting with my manager, some of my peers, the people, business partners who are my primary team. So those syncs really help and then, I believe a lot of responsibility is on my boss's shoulders. He's the one who's managing me in Pakistan, my peer in India, partners in the US. So he is the one who is, you know, communicating the bigger strategy and the bigger picture every week, like literally. It's such a fast-moving industry that priorities change and the dynamics change. So communication is the key. I know it sounds cliché, but that's how it is, and then it comes back to hiring the right person.
[00:10:41] Adriaan: Yeah. Have you ever read the book The Culture Map by Erin Meyer?
[00:10:45] Hassan: I think you are the one who recommended it to me.
[00:10:47] Adriaan: Oh, yeah. When we spoke, because this is really exactly what the book is all about, right? The cultural differences, I think around six or seven attributes on how to make decisions, on how flat or hierarchical the organization is, on how to give feedback. And one of the things that I had to learn as the CEO of my company is that I was working at the time with a lot of Ukrainian colleagues, and the Ukrainian culture is much more hierarchical in terms of decision-making process. So actually they like the boss to make a decision, in this case, me. What a Dutch culture is, everyone huddled together, we're all gonna make the, make this into a voting exercise. And I remember in the beginning that when I, you know, started to expand the team and start to involve more and more people in some of the things that we were doing or decisions that we had to make, is that there was a hesitation, and I could never really understand why. And only after I read the book I understood it's the culture, and there's no right or wrong, that's just, you know, how people are, growing up and what the values are. And Ukraine is a much more hierarchical culture. And when I realized that, that's when I also understood, "Okay, I need to give them permission to share, and also it's okay for me to once in a while just say, 'This is what we're gonna do,' and I don't need to involve everyone," which would be, you know, a death sin in the Netherlands, but very normal in a culture like Ukraine.
[00:12:08] Hassan: Yeah. Well, thanks for the recommendation. I just looked it up online. It seems, sounds very interesting.
[00:12:15] Adriaan: Yeah. Hey, Hassan, I wanna switch a little bit. We're gonna talk about AI, right? AI is front and center. You are in the thick of it, DigitalOcean. What are you seeing from a macro perspective company-wide? What is the general consensus where the world is going? are-- do you follow, the, what OpenAI and Anthropic are screaming AI, we need to slow down all of a sudden? What is happening in your world?
[00:12:37] Hassan: So this is a great question. I mean, I'm just going to read a little from my, you know, DigitalOcean's website. So here is what we say officially. So most clouds only cover one to two layers or fragment all five across 300 plus disconnected services. What we do is all five layers. So one is infrastructure, there is core cloud, then there is inference engine, there's data and learning, and there are managed agents. Now, DigitalOcean has continuously talked to us, the employees, that, hey, we are the cloud infrastructure provider, but we are not an ordinary one. We are providing the five layers of service, as I just mentioned. Imagine being part of this company where we are building something for the developers who are AI native. Just a few months ago we were calling them DNEs, the digital native enterprises, and we're technically calling them the developers born in the AI era. Now, we are part of a company which itself is in the business of, making AI development possible through five layers of service. So what happens is, you know, we continuously talk about AI. We have an AI task force. We meet every week, and that is particularly focused on HR, what are our approved tools and how small things can make a difference. I'll give So even, you know, Slackbot, that's an underrated tool. And a lot of conversations are happening all the time on Slack, and it's sometimes overwhelming. But what Slackbot does is it pulls out some trends and patterns and analysis. So what we did was in Pakistan, we, shifted to a hybrid model five days a week, you know, working from office to three days in office and two days from home. This was a change and, you know, Karachi is, a place which has traffic challenges and a lot more. So me wearing my employee centricity hat, I did some sort of an analysis through Slackbot. Hey, from this date till today, we have, done the hybrid model. What's happening? What happens in from Monday to Wednesday, and what on Thursday and Friday? You know, got back to me with some sort of an analysis. So to my surprise, it was also about productivity. Now, is that the days people are working from home, some sort of a pattern is that the strategic problems, the research, the focused issues which needed attention, are happening on Thursdays and Fridays. And then from Monday to Tuesday, as we are physically present in office, we are physically talking to each other. A lot of day-to-day customer needs are being fulfilled. And if I myself, I am in office, my customer is an internal customer, so they walk in, I talk to them, I engage with them, I collaborate with them. So I resonate with what Slackbot presented to me. This is a one small example. This actually defended the case for a hybrid working. And of course, I can, you know, talk to my leadership, "Hey, this is what it's telling us. What are your priorities?" And so on and so forth. And then other tools, you know... what happens is DigitalOcean's overall aspiration to make developers' life easier, the AI So that puts us in a certain place of responsibility that, hey, we have to, make AI the part and parcel of the way we do things on a day-to-day basis. So if I request my boss for a headcount, I'll first see, can I, can this job be done through an AI tool or something? That becomes a very interesting conversation. So the organograms of the past, which were made in PowerPoint on the Visio they will be agents and humans.
[00:16:39] Adriaan: So how do you then look at your org chart? Have you, in the age of AI, right? Like how do you now think about job description? How do you now think about the Christmas tree, right?
[00:16:51] Hassan: So, a great question. I think a work in progress, but let's say it's, mapping the needs of, the day-to-day. So again, it's about creating that lake of all the queries which are coming to us as in HR. It may be ranging from the operational queries to recruiting, to talent, to succession, to retention. Now, if you start putting the details together, that is where the devil lies. Then you can easily club them, cluster them, and bucket them and see, okay, these are the needs for which if I keep answering, it is the same repetitive answer. This is built in an AI chatbot or a tool, what we need to do is a good job of change management and communication. "Hey, manager, thanks for reaching out. Talk to this bot, and it's on this centralized knowledge management system." Old habits die hard, and again, back to our culture. The human-to-human connection matters, walking into the HR office matters. And then they say, "Hey, we have Hassan," and I'm gonna grab a cup of tea and talk to him. "Hey, I'm facing a problem. What What's the approach I'm gonna take?" And it's a bit uncourteous for me to say, "Hey, thanks, but you mind going to the portal and talking to your coach," which is an AI bot. So it's a work in progress. It's a change, but I believe with some effort we're gonna get there.
[00:18:16] Adriaan: So do you, because I'm, I've, I speak to a lot of different talent leaders about this topic, right? Do you actually look now at your org chart where you slot in AI agents or whole roles disappear and they are now run by AI agents? Like, how do you make that judgment call and also the ratios maybe between number of employees versus agents? I don't even know if , that's a valid ratio, but how do you look at that?
[00:18:41] Hassan: Took a very simple approach. I mean, one of the, strategies which was a very, you know, no-brainer in one of our support functions where, you know, the agents were talking to the customers, the human agents. Based on the natural attrition, you know, we evaluated each and every position. Hey, do we need a replacement or can this be dealt with by an automated agent? And that is exactly where this change started happening. So in a matter of a few months, we did not take any physical human replacement and the contact still continued. That is the overall strategy we have taken. So it's about testing what we-- our assumptions. It's not only following the, hey, AI agenda, it's also seeing, okay, baby steps, is it working for us or not? And where do we actually need the human intervention?
[00:19:30] Adriaan: Yeah. Does the entire organization have access to AI?
[00:19:35] Hassan: Yes.
[00:19:36] Adriaan: Yeah. And are there, and everyone can experiment freely with it, or are there certain guardrails in place? Interesting. Yeah.
[00:19:43] Hassan: There are in place, but the access is for everyone.
[00:19:46] Adriaan: Yeah. 'Cause I've seen 50/50 on my side. Some companies give full access, other companies are more restrictive. In our case, we see that only 20% of our employees really embrace AI, and they are responsible for 80% of our token usage, right? That's what we see.
[00:20:04] Hassan: E-learning on the responsible use of AI and, the idea was, one, let them play, and two, but let them know that what's acceptable and what's not.
[00:20:12] Adriaan: Yeah. Hey, what are some of the needs of the business from an HR perspective with regards to AI?
[00:20:18] Hassan: From the HR perspective is, you know, honestly, it is evolving at such a rapid pace because we are in the business of managed hosting and two, our, you know, parent company in the cloud infrastructure, that our HR needs are continuously being responsive to the business needs. We are, you know, high on bringing in good talent, the human talent as well, because they are the ones who are gonna help us on the AI agenda and where is the fine balance between AI and the human needs? So I would not say that we have a clear structured document that outlines, okay, these are the needs, but it's about the... See, we cannot even predict how three months from now will look like. What can be the new innovations and revelations in AI, world. So we have to be responsive and agile enough to support the business.
[00:21:17] Adriaan: Do you see that there's a difference in Pakistan versus US/Western European terms of adaption or accessibility or how people think about it?
[00:21:28] Hassan: There is. I think, we in Pakistan need a little bit more a pat on the back for using AI because see, it solves problems. It gets the job done. And sometimes. See, again, the economies matter, the talent matters, the job security, these come into play at times when people feel, "Okay, if AI can get my job done, am I still relevant or not?" So these insecurities are very normal and human. It's not about my company, it's generally in our culture. So the sense of security needs to be prevailed that, hey, you can… Eventually, at the end of the day, it's a tool for our benefit, and you can add certain more value. So that is a bit of a challenge.
[00:22:13] Adriaan: Yeah. What excites you? What are some of the things that you're now working towards within your team, within HR, being at the forefront in an AI company that you think is really gonna help and elevate and maybe change HR?
[00:22:29] Hassan: So, you know, the basic operational services were something the day-to-day HR queries that used to come to us, even to me. Because see, people don't know if this is a business partner or a people…
[00:22:41] Adriaan: I know, I know. Just, I remember those days. Yeah.
[00:22:44] Hassan: Yeah. So they know the face and they talk to us. Now, continuous education of our chatbot who actually fetches data and the information from the internal knowledge portal, that is where we save a lot of time and queries. So that's one. Would be, you know, we have country-wise policies on labor and employment laws. Now, this can help the managers manage their teams in a way that it provides them a sounding board. So that sounding board is which they used to come to us earlier. Now, they still come to us, but, you know, our answers used to be situation to situation. Now, this is a tool which will provide them a structured framework to manage their teams, which may be performance, exits, voluntary terminations, et cetera. So I believe that is where we are heading and the world is heading, that we as humans become more of strategic advisors and partners and manage the human element; the repetitive and the recurring nature of transactions, they are through AI.
[00:23:59] Adriaan: Yeah. We're seeing something similar. For you, right, how do you balance with the different time zones, the two dual roles, and how do you navigate this? And also translating things on the global level versus a local level?
[00:24:15] Hassan: Well, first of all, I'm quite lucky that the gentleman I am business partner to, he's in Dubai, my boss is in New Jersey. Of the team is in Pakistan. So I work from 11:00 AM to 8:00 PM, you know, on a regular basis. So two to three hours are matched with my manager. So that is how we figure out the time. And then secondly, it is about regular syncs and seeing, okay, how my week is looking like. And, you know, there are days, mid-year reviews and annual cycles, then there are maybe times when we have to, you know, align our timings more. But, I think one, give it time. Two, understand each other and each other's priorities. And three, just, put in place some ways of work that, hey, these are the broad directions, and then in the region level, I'm empowered to do stuff.
[00:25:05] Adriaan: In the infra, AI infra, world, right? Talent is in very high demand, and especially on some of these niche roles, it's very hard to get talent. Maybe for people that have been inspired by hearing your story, what is your recommendation for finding this hard to find talent, and what is your recommendation if someone would be interested to potentially explore Pakistan as a potential option to hire some of this talent?
[00:25:33] Hassan: I mean, I would say don't let the perceptions take your, you know, decision-making ability. The capital of Pakistan, Islamabad, to Karachi. Now, let alone the international people, even within Pakistan, the cities enjoy a different perception. The prime minister sits there, the federal cabinet sits there, and it's secure. And Karachi was, the chaotic, the business hub, concrete everywhere, a lot of potential and ex-capital. So I actually, you know, rather than going by the perception, I said, "Okay, I'll go and experience." And it's been two half years. wonders for my career. And similarly, I can say that people who are willing to explore Pakistani talent, I would say, give it a pilot, give it a test, see how things go. And then again, as I said earlier, it's very well-priced. It's good work ethic, good English, good communication skills. And, you know, with a little bit of initial hand-holding, they can do wonders.
[00:26:42] Adriaan: Yeah. Amazing. Hey, what excites you about the next couple of months, Hassan?
[00:26:47] Hassan: So what excites me is, even, you know, we are a business within a business, Cloudways. So DigitalOcean is you know, cloud infrastructure and there are a lot of options of synergies. So the whole idea of global operating model and then it being executed locally, that keeps on inspiring me. Presenting and making Cloudways as a good employer in Pakistan, I mean, there is a huge potential. I mean, it comes back to the idea that presenting that Pakistani talent is reliable. And then there is a company in Pakistan who actually has made a name, serves the needs of international clients and is doing well. So maybe, the strengthening of employer brand, I would say is something very exciting for me.
[00:27:37] Adriaan: Yeah, Cool. Hassan, thank you so much for your time. Thank you for staying up a little bit later. What is the best way for people to connect with you? Is that over LinkedIn?
[00:27:46] Hassan: Yeah, absolutely. LinkedIn, I'm quite active. I mean, once or twice a day I do check my LinkedIn and they can simply type my name, Hassan Arshad, or maybe add the word Cloudways. They'll find me.
[00:27:55] Adriaan: Yeah. Amazing. Thank you so much, Hassan.
[00:27:59] Hassan: Thanks, Adriaan. It was a pleasure.